On August Bank Holiday Monday 1935 there was a Gala and Carnival advertised at the stadium which included a Band Contest, Bathing Beauty competition and sports with bicycle races.
In May 1935, Barnsley Council refused the application for greyhound racing at the Old Mill, meaning that no betting meetings could take place. The stadium probably closed shortly after this.
The sports field still exists alongside a small development of business units next to the A61. The Tollgate Hotel was demolished in the 1990's.